Showing posts with label Commitment of Traders. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Commitment of Traders. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 1, 2017

A Few Thoughts on Stocks Here 11-1-17

Today there is an FOMC statement to be released.

Tech stocks have pushed higher the last week, but to me it appear to be an exhaustion type move, as evidenced by the following chart.

Click on Chart to Enlarge

This chart is XLK on a daily time frame.  It is a tech stock ETF.  What I have drawn is an upper channel line which connects the previous price peaks during the uptrend.  A touch or break of such a trend channel line is often an exhaustion point for a move.

Couple that with the fact that the recent gap up from last Friday was the largest gap up in a couple years, it smacks of an exhaustion gap from a charting standpoint.  Is that gap up on the earnings news almost 2 years into a 65% run up in prices a "smart money" gap?  Or is it a "dumb money" type gap after the news is out?  I think more of the later.

Click on Chart to Enlarge

This chart is a weekly chart of the Dow futures contract with associated Commitment of Traders data below the price chart.  When analyzing the CoT data, there are a few common patterns that show up at reversal points on the chart.

One of the key points in CoT is always extreme positioning between the market participants and their historical range of contracts held.  We have seen extremes in the chart for sure as it pushed to new highs in 2016.  Other index contracts are hitting or near extremes on this rally also.

However, an even more notable signal than the extreme position is a "blow off" pattern in the futures where the "smart money" commercial traders hold an extreme position, but then price continues to rise and there is a break from their pattern of selling on price rises.  Instead we see the commercial group decreasing their short position substantially as prices rise.  That indicates a typical finale to a rally where the speculators "won".  They cashed out into a strongly rising prices.

That is what we are seeing on this Dow chart.  The commercial pattern of selling into the price rise was standard until October began.  Then for the last month, price has risen very sharply while commercials have bought and large specs have sold.

Once the run is done, this could result in a substantial decline, even a bear market.

Not all of the index contracts are displaying the same pattern, but this one has a classic bull market peak type of look to it, and so I am paying attention.


On a shorter term note, I back tested SPY data looking at opening prices outside the upper bollinger band on a gap up as is occurring today.  I also added various other conditions which are currently present in the market to gauge the short term expectation.

The only real significant finding is for the same day.  There is about 2 to 4 times greater MAX loss than MAX gain on the day of this finding.  The forward returns after the close of the signal day were flat to typical.

So given this tendency for a close below the open, and some of the exhaustion signals occurring, I wonder if the FOMC news will lead to a sell the news response here.

We will see.


Pete

Tuesday, October 31, 2017

Coffee Prices on the Brink of a Major Rally - November 2017

Click on Chart to Enlarge

The above chart is a 5 year chart of coffee futures prices, covering the last couple bear market lows and some intervening bullish phases.

Currently prices are retesting a spike low which occurred in June of 2017.  And of note, there is now record net short positioning in the large speculators even as price is stabilizing at a higher bottom than the June low.

This indicates that there is a tremendous amount of short covering possible to be unleashed on a price advance.  The last 2 major bullish phases were 50% and 100% roughly in a year or less after comparable positioning among the major market players.

Not shown on the chart above is that "managed money" category of the positions is record net short basically equaling the level of the June low, at which point a 2 month 30% price rise occurred.

It certainly seems possible that price action will become "sloppy" before a rally occurs. 

But to me it makes sense to take every "buy" signal generated in a daily or weekly time frame from here forward.  And don't underestimate the potential price rise that could occur over the next several months.  From the visible data of the past major rallies, a 30-100% rally over the next 6 months would be reasonable.

I have eyes on purchasing JO, which is an ETN to participate in this potential move.

Pete

Thursday, July 20, 2017

Gold and Silver Prices Finding a Bottom? Based on CoT Positions I Think So - July 2017

Click on Chart to Enlarge

The chart here is a chart of gold prices and the Commitment of Traders data for the last couple years.  This is produced on Barchart.com

What is notable here is that the red line, which is the "smart money" commerical traders, is showing the highest reading going back until the bottom of the bear market in late 2015.  Basically with prices where they currently are, these producers are not seeing the necessity of hedging much.

Also, it is rare for the red line to ever cross above 0 as it did at the bottom of the last bear market.  Basically the commercials are totally unhedged and are in a small speculative long position when that occurs.

The other side of the commercial position is the large speculators.  And you can see they have the lowest net long position since the bottom of the bear market.

I am making note of this here, because it seems very possible that these levels are significant enough to form a corrective bottom in gold and lead to a significant advance.

If prices are able to break below this month's low, I would expect that commercials would continue to support prices and the chop may continue.

Monday, July 13, 2015

Stock Index Commitment of Traders Data Suggests Strong Bullish Run Ahead

I took time this evening to review the recent Commitment of Trader's data compiled for the major US stock indexes.  And there has been a large move of smart money into the long side of futures in the last 2 reporting periods.  As of this past week's reporting period this has actually pushed the smart money "hedgers" to a net long position.  They typically are net short and have not gone net long at too many points in recent years.

The last two period of time where they moved from extended net short to a net long total where at distinctly significant lows.
  • August 16th 2011 - Dec 27th 2011 was mostly net long by commercials
  • July 6th 2010 - Sept 14th 2010 was mostly net long by commercials
Those periods both marked the beginning of a couple months of wide range trading as stocks formed a support level and then launched into major bullish runs.

At this point, with significant negative news on the world front and the smart money loading into US stocks, it seems to me that the big move in coming months will be to the upside in stocks.

So there are several ways to play this, but at this time my suggestion is to take only the long side trades from here in US stocks.


Pete

Tuesday, June 9, 2015

Commitment of Traders Update - Stocks and Crude Oil

I have been following the CoT data on a number of markets closely for several years.  I spend most of my analysis effort on US stocks in general, and that is no different for CoT data.

Recently as the US stocks have traded in very tight range for months, there have not been major extremes in positioning long or short.  Currently as prices have recently made new all time highs, there has not been any major sell signal or accumulation of shorts by the "smart money". 

Generally the pattern is that smart money will sell heavily at the highs, sometimes with some divergence as is typical in markets, and sometimes after forced short covering.  But at our recent highs, the situation is either that they are NOT ready to sell en masse yet, OR there is a massive divergence period which would imply that the bull market is ending.  As always price action is the final answer.

I did want to alert readers here to what could be a very telling pattern and trade set-up in crude oil.  Coming off the March low in crude there has been a massive short-covering rally in crude oil.  The underlying position data is interesting and probably should be alarming for the bulls.  There has been NO increase in long speculative positions in the entire 49% rally off the lows.  In aggregate ALL the buying has been short covering.  This is occurring in a downtrend.  Short-covering in a downtrend with no new interest on the long side is NOT a healthy bull pattern.  And yet it gets WORSE for the bulls........

 At the March low the large speculators - which normally are most long at TOPS and which normally buy increasingly as price rises in an uptrend - had actually bought on the way down from November to March, to the point that their long position was basically equal to their all time high in net long at the June 2014 top before the massive decline.

And as already stated, they have not increased their long positions at all during the rally since March.  So here is the question........Is this because the CAN'T increase their long position?  There is a limit to the amount of funds they have, and certainly historical numbers can give floors and ceilings to the probable max capacity of $ deployment available. 

If the answer is that they can't buy more, then once this rally fizzles out, crude will certainly plummet again before the bear market ends.  The seasonal trends in crude are positive into the end of summer.  So it may be that oil holds up or sideways for a while before that happens.

The alternate possibility is that the funds have a "stash" of cash that they have yet to commit to the long side of the market, but given the way these things work, that seems like a very unlikely possibility.

So my suggestion here is to take all crude oil sell signals that develop according to your system or technique moving forward from this point.  I don't know how easy it will be to catch a top of this rally or if it already occurred.  But it may take a few attempts to get a position that sticks for a major decline.  I plan to speculate with put options at key points or signals moving forward.

Pete

Monday, March 9, 2015

US Dollar Index Showing Bearish Divergence at Extreme OverBought Conditions In Both Price and Time

Commitment of Traders Us Dollar
Click on Chart or US Dollar Index to Enlarge

This chart is a weekly chart of the US dollar index with Commitment of Traders data below.  These charts are available at Barchart.com.  What is apparent is the massive rise in the speculative net long position, mirrored by the massive net short position by smart money/commercials.  So what does this mean?  A few things I believe...

  • First long term, this trend is not done.  There will likely need to be at least a weekly time frame bearish divergence on the technical analysis to end the trend.
  • By all measures, this move is historically extreme.  It is "overdone" and will likely result in a significant correction of the current uptrend in the relatively near term.
A few nuances of the chart suggest to me that the top for this leg up is close at hand.  First, there is a lower high in the speculator's positions in the last few weeks, creating a divergence that is typical of the end of a move, and is seen at all the other tops of importance on this chart as well.  Second, open interest is at a considerably lower point than its peak for the uptrend.  This also shows decreasing participation in the uptrend, and suggests that the leg up is ending.  You can also see the open interest (purple line in middle pane) make lower peaks as price reached ultimate peaks in the past.

So when can we expect the move to end?

One technique I have discussed before on this blog is the use of an upper channel line combined with technical divergence.  


MACD Bearish Divergence UUP
Click on Chart of UUP etf to Enlarge

This chart is the UUP etf which is an unleveraged 1:1 mirror fund of the US Dollar Index.  I have shown an upper channel line in the chart, and price is just below it.  Certainly price could top right here, but a touch of the channel on further strength would be a great exit into strength in my opinion if you are long.

Also note the sharp bearish divergence on the MACD study in the lower pane.  View this as a "set-up" indicating that shorter term signals can be used for exit of longs or entry of shorts.

If the MACD now crosses down it would be a very simple exit signal that I think should be respected.  However, if price breaks to new highs, I would have to suggest covering a short position, but be willing to re-enter if there is yet another bearish signal while the divergence maintains.  

That being said, trying to catch a correction in a trend is not where most people will make consistent money.  The best idea may be to wait for a sell off in coming months, and then get serious about timing entry on the long side in expectation of a break to yet higher high later this year.

Pete

Sunday, March 8, 2015

2015 Stock Market, Bull Market Top - Bearish Divergence


2015 Stock Market, Bull Market Top - Bearish Divergence


It appears likely to me that the current bull market in stocks since 2009 is over or is in its finals stages. Whether it can be prolonged a few weeks or months, is probably quite reasonable, but I doubt that the current 5th year of the decade will have the same shine as it historically has.

There is bearish divergence in price, sentiment and breadth in the market on multiple time frame.

Additionally, price has now made a failed breakout and reversed below prior highs in several indexes, which is a typical topping pattern as smart money sells heavily into new high trying to unload right at the top.

Toward the end of the video above I was looking for some prior published material I posted on crude oil and did not find it in a blog post.  But the information is contained in a video I published on YouTube from June 18th 2014.  The video did not cover the Commitment of Traders data, only the technical analysis and pattern analysis.  So a longer term monthly chart of crude oil with the CoT positions is shown below.  From the green line on the bottom pane you can see speculators' positions reaching new all time highs in 2014 despite lower price peaks compared to 2013, 2011, and 2008.

Crude Oil Commitment of Traders Chart

The point here again is that crude oil price gains were made by speculators buying.  And there is no actual intent for use by the large specs.  It is only leveraged speculation for profit.  And the subsequent vertical price decline in 2014 (similar to 2008) shows the type of move that can occur with unwinding of that leverage with no real tangible demand.  Interestingly, it appears that there are still currently more long contracts held by speculators that there were held at the PEAK of the 2008 high in oil.  So, in the longer term view, it seems likely that oil will continue its bear market - I would guess breaking the 2008 lows, and possibly the 2001 and/or 1998 lows.

So the situation in stocks is that the bull market has been pushed higher on record margin debt, which has peaked (so far anyway) ahead of price - as it has at the last two bull market peaks.  And this fits in with a divergence theory of market trend changes where you will see the underlying buying/selling behavior peak and diverge prior to the price peak and turn.  The following link is from a website that I am just posting to give you a visual of the margin situation.

I don't want to over complicate the situation.  Bull market tops will lull the crowd into risk complacency.  All things move in cycles, and there will be an end to the current upward cycle in stock prices, followed by new cycles again.  So on a pragmatic basis the question is whether you have an objective strategy for exiting this market.  Do you?  

I have suggested various forms of trailing stops that can be used in the market or as an analytical red flag to take action.  I will make an update in the near future with further details of trade ideas and chart points at which I would suggest price has not only hinted, but CONFIRMED that the market is likely topped for investment purposes.

Pete

Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Why I Expect Oil to Rally When Everyone is Bearish

crude oil commitment of traders
Click on Chart to Enlarge

This is a chart of crude oil with Commitment of Traders positions below the price chart.  I wanted to give a little more detail on my perspective on the energy complex.

Of note on the large speculators positions, they have gotten progressively more short until early December which is their normal pattern.  They are the money that drives speculative trends.  Interestingly however, as price began to accelerate down ever faster at the beginning of December, the large specs have not increased the short position.  At this point there is a bullish divergence in the positions.  So crude oil has fallen 33% without the large specs increasing their short position.  This type of divergence is pretty classic as a trend ending pattern in underlying positions.

For basic understanding, first realize that the money that drives trends comes from somewhere.  And when the biggest money that there is, which drives the price trends, no longer follows the trend, the implication is that they do not have any more fund capacity collectively to participate in or push that trend.

So we have certainly ample evidence of that with a multi week massive decline but no further shorting by the large specs.  Additionally, there is now in the last few weeks at least a modest return to the normal commercial/smart money pattern of buying as prices decline.  So that indicates to me that the very directional commercial capitulation stage of this decline is likely waning.

Additionally, the daily MACD is demonstrating bullish divergence, and the money flow index is demonstrating pretty classic reversal divergence.  The money flow index basically looks at price and volume and typically demonstrates a substantial lead time with prices.

Taken together, it appears to me that energy prices (including natural gas, heating oil, gasoline) are likely to stage a rally very soon.  Whether or not it will be a bear market rally I don't know.  I would lean towards believing that because of no weekly time frame MACD divergence currently at these lows.  I think it will more likely turn into a volatile basing period or a rally followed by a failed breakdown to new lows before prices may bottom longer term.  But that is looking out kind of far for my purposes.  Really I am just interested in catching the next swing up, which I expect to be quite swift given the major oversold condition of this market.

XLE bullish divergence
Click on Chart to Enlarge

For those more interested in equities, this is XLE which is a major ETF covering oil and energy related stocks.  Notice how it has not maintained the aggressive decline that oil has.  And it also is displaying a drawn out bullish divergence on the MACD with a more classic chart pattern bottom with a failed breakout below the December 16th low, followed by an immediate reversal higher.  This indicates a stop running move in the market and that the buying interest was picking up right at that low as other (dumb money) was selling out or shorting in the break.  This makes the dumb money about as wrong as possible and the smart money about as right as possible.

For trading purposes the XLE etf may be a better purchase or near term speculation than crude oil itself.  That remains to be seen, but just understand there are several ways to participate in this probable reversal.

Sunday, November 23, 2014

The Down Trend Is Ending In the Yen - Signs of Exhaustion in the Commitment of Traders Data

Click on Chart to Enlarge

Click on Chart to Enlarge

The chart on top is the FXY etf which is the Japanese Yen.  The lower chart is the CoT data, but it covers a longer time period than the top chart, so checks the dates for correspondence.

I am pointing it out here because it is displaying one of the most significant and sure signs of exhaustion there is based upon the Commitment of Trader's data.  So this trend appears to be ending, and one could look to initiate speculative longs soon with outstanding reward to risk ratios.

Of note is the horizontal support line.  The low at the beginning of 2014 marks the point of maximum net short by  speculators.  This can be seen in the chart of the CoT data below.  That point is a multi year extreme in net short by large specs.  Even on the move to lower lows in FXY, the specs didn't get more short, so this shows that their selling capacity is exhausted - it is a type of divergence or non-confirmation with the price trend.

Now the other interesting thing here is that when price broke that horizontal support, it led to the smart money/commercials, actually having to sell into lower prices for a few weeks, which is opposite their style.  This is a hallmark of the end of a trend when the commercials have to capitulate and take a massive loss.

I will link here to a post I made about cotton in 2011, because it accurately showed this pattern in reverse - as a topping pattern - on this blog as the top occurred in cotton before a massive bear market took place in the following year or so.

So one could look here to short the USD/Yen pair on appropriate signals.  Also one could look to buy FXY call options with several months to expiration with strikes in the 80-85 range after careful analysis.  Also, YCL is a 2x leveraged bullish Yen fund, which would be used as a leveraged equity play to go long on appropriate signals.

I personally am looking at some call options on FXY, but currently have no position.



Wednesday, July 31, 2013

Commitment of Traders Stock Index Update July 2013

Commitment of Traders Stock Index Update

This video covers the recent commitment of traders report data relevant to the attempted breakout of the May 2013 highs.  I give you an interpretation of what to look for and a brief discussion of possible short entry strategy and initial profit target.  If prices move to new highs basis the S&P 500, then it may be a continuation and force further short covering as the short positions have built substantially between 1653-1697 on the S&P 500.  Further price increases will pressure those newly established shorts to cover which will provide buying fuel for the rally.  This really is a key level for stocks.

Saturday, July 20, 2013

Commitment of Traders Stock Index Update

CoT Index of Combined Stock Indexes
Click on Chart to Enlarge

This week's CoT report includes trader positions through Tuesday as prices approached the May highs on the S&P 500 and the Dow 30, but did not break the old high yet.

There was a pretty large increase in the commercial/smart money short position on the week.  Next week's report will be key for analysis because it will include the push to new highs in the cash indexes on the Dow and S&P 500.  If we see another large jump in the selling and a move back to near record short position, then we could have more evidence of a failed breakout attempt.

As price made new highs in May of this year, the smart money was positioned heavily short, but then covered shorts on the run up in May after the breakout.  So that could certainly happen again.  But what we are looking for here is the sentiment of the smart money.


The CoT rate of change gave a typical minor buy signal in mid June.  That will typically occur in conjunction with the end of a correction in the markets.  Interestingly, the market pushed a bit lower after the signal came, but then has reached new highs.  In sustained trends that signal should maintain price above the corrective low.

So in our case a move below the June lows would be indication of failure to maintain the price trend both on a technical analysis level, and also in terms of the CoT data.  A failed breakout of the May high followed by a close below the June low, would be probable indication of a much larger correction or even possibly a bear market in effect in the stock indexes.

So my suggestion is that the June low be perfectly clear as the make or break line for stock market longs here.  Now it would certainly be possible for a false break of the June low and the formation of a large trading range, but for now, keep it simple and understand the risk if prices are to break that low, especially if it occurs more rapidly than the rally since June took to form.

Monday, March 25, 2013

Stock Market Update 3-25-13

Stock Market Update 3-25-13

This video covers this past week's Commitment of Traders report data and discusses the technical situation in the Nasdaq and some possible technical triggers to enter short positions or exit long on the stock indexes.

Friday, March 22, 2013

"Smart Money" Continues to Increase Selling

This week's Commitment of Traders report shows that the commercial traders have continued to increase their net short position compared to last week.

This does not include this week's reaction and changes following the FOMC meeting, but with negligible price activity following announcement I would not anticipate that being a significant factor in the upcoming reporting period.

I plan to post a video update of the CoT charts this weekend, but the spread between the smart money and the speculative money is extreme.  When the smart money gets very heavily net short there are typically 2 outcomes.  The first is for an imminent topping process and for stocks to fall afterwards.  The second is for a low volatility and possibly persistent rise in the markets that leads the smart money to undergo a somewhat drawn out short covering process as prices rise.

For the intermediate term a trailing stop type of strategy out to be effective for long positions because the market is at high risk of correction based on the smart money's heavy short position.  But if the correction is not forth coming stocks may churn higher on low volatility allowing a smooth rise in the trailing stop.

Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Nearing Confirmation of A Correction- But Short-Term Oversold

Click on Chart to Enlarge

This is a 60 min chart of SPY.  The MACD is oversold indicating the market may attempt a rally.  It would be better to see a bullish divergence develop before considering a new long entry.

Given the momentum set-up with the weekly and monthly stochastics overbought and the weekly now in a sell signal formation, I think the better opportunity is to wait for the likely rally and then look to short/inverse on the next sell signal if price meets resistance at or below the recent highs of 9/14/12.

Click on Chart to Enlarge

The spread between the smart money commercial futures traders and the large speculators is at a 3 year low indicating the smart money is heavily short with a bearish outlook for prices.  The last times the spread was this large were June 2009 before a 4 week correction, around New Year's 2009 before the final plunge into the 2009 bear market low, and the first week of Oct 2008 before "the crash" plunge into the Oct 10th low.  The time before that was late February 2007 just before a surprise 4% plunge day in the markets and an 8% overall correction.

The point being that there is no other real interpretation of this than at least a modestly bearish one.

The correction off the recent high in the SPY etf is now 8 days long.  The prior longest correction since the June low was 9 days.  If the decline continues to 1415 on the S&P 500 cash, the decline will be larger than any other pullback since the June low as well.  So further downside would create an overbalancing of both price and time suggesting a correction of at least the June-Sept leg up is occurring.

Of note is that open interest rose sharply in the last reporting period with an increase in the commercial net short position.  This indicates that there is NEW hedging or commercial short interest coming in at these level.  While this may seem trivial, another pattern which occurs is for commercials to go heavily short, and then cover their shorts on falling open interest as the market pushes higher and puts them at a loss.  That pattern tends to lead to a sustainable price advance.  We are NOT seeing that right now, which indicates that we may be making a very important high here.

Again my suggestion is to exit longs and growth stocks, or trail stops tightly.




Sunday, September 16, 2012

Stock Market Analysis 9-16-12

Stock Market Analysis 9-16-12

This video covers multiple time frame technical analysis on stocks as well as CoT data.  Stocks could be making a major top here.  I suggest tightening stops on any long positions and growth stocks.  Check the video out for further details.

Monday, September 3, 2012

Major Stock Index Selling By Smart Money

Click on Chart to Enlarge

The commercial "smart money" traders increased their selling in stock futures this past reporting period making them the most net short in over a year.  The last times they were this heavily short were at the July 2011 and May 2011 tops.  While a signal like this can fail to lead to a major correction, in the context of a double top/failed breakout I wouldn't bet on it.  At a bare minimum I suggest having in the market trailing stops on long positions or growth stocks.  Remember, our goal as individual traders is to observe what the big players are doing, anticipate what they are likely to do next, and to position ourselves with them.  So they are more bearish than in the last year or so.  Are you?

Combined with a failed breakout of the April 2012 high, this reinforces that a correction is likely from these levels.  But as noted in the recent video, it would be out of character for the market to push above the recent August high and then make a correction.  A new high would likely be a continuation point.

Click on Chart to Enlarge

Click on Chart to Enlarge

Notice that the bollinger bands are squeezed tightly on SPY.  Not shown is the ADX/DMI which shows that the daily DMI has been below 20 for 2.5 months.  As it approached 20 two weeks ago, it turned down as the market failed to breakout.  Recall several posts talking about this explosive set up in the past.  Most recently it occurred in gold resulting in an upside breakout.  But the key is the watch for a close OUTSIDE the bands with both bands expanding.  When that happens in this situation it typically leads to a sharp price movement, though it may only last 1-2 weeks.

Click on Chart to Enlarge

The VIX/VXV ratio recent spiked lower again similar to what occurred in March of this year.  What this mean is that short term volatility is out of balance with longer term volatility expectations.  As you can see on the chart, that has often led to substantial corrections in stocks with on overall increase in volatility and a rebalancing of the VIX/VXV.  The other possibility is for volatility to remain low and the longer term volatility shrinks to rebalance the ratio.  If that happens it would likely be in the context of a continuing low volatility market advance.

As an additional note, the VIX has been running high relative to historical volatility.  This also often happens prior to market corrections.  The option market does not believe the current low volatility trade is sustainable.

At this point the US dollar looks set to make a continuation of its advance, and commodities have run very hot for several weeks and are likely to correct.  So I think we are likely to see a deflationary theme type sell off here again with most assets down and the US dollar up.